Retention Monies in NSW Payment Claims
⚠️ Compliance Warning
Incorrectly calculating or failing to claim the release of retention monies can lead to significant cash flow issues and disputes under the Security of Payment Act.
1. Field Name and Definition
Retention Monies refers to the portion of payment withheld by the principal or head contractor from progress payments as security for the satisfactory completion of construction work and rectification of any defects during the defects liability period.
This field appears on Payment Claims to identify:
- The total amount of retention currently held
- When retained amounts become due for release
- The calculation basis for retention deductions
- Any partial releases of retention already made
Including retention monies details ensures transparency in payment calculations and helps track when these funds should be released back to the contractor.
2. Legal Requirements
Statutory Framework
Under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) ("the Act"), while retention monies are not specifically mandated as a separate field, they form part of the "calculated amount" of the payment claim under section 13(2)(a).
The Act requires payment claims to state the amount claimed, which inherently includes any adjustments for retention. Failing to properly account for retention can result in an incorrect claimed amount, potentially affecting the claim's validity.
Relevant Case Law
Clarity in Calculation
In Clarence Street Pty Ltd v Isis Projects Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 391, the Court of Appeal emphasised that payment claims must clearly show how the claimed amount is calculated. This includes identifying deductions such as retention monies.
Avoiding Ambiguity
Protectavale Pty Ltd v K2K Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1248 reinforced that ambiguity in payment calculations, including retention arrangements, can lead to disputes and potentially invalid claims.
Consequences of Incorrect Completion
- Overstated claims: Failing to deduct retention may result in claiming more than contractually entitled.
- Invalid payment schedules: Respondents may issue payment schedules disputing the entire claim.
- Adjudication complications: Adjudicators may struggle to determine the correct amount payable.
- Loss of credibility: Systematic errors in retention calculations can damage commercial relationships.
3. Practical Guidance
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Review the Contract: Locate retention provisions (typically in payment clauses), identify the retention percentage (e.g., 5% or 10%), note any caps, and check for staged release provisions.
- Calculate Current Retention: Determine the total value of work completed, apply the contractual retention percentage, deduct any previously released amounts, and verify against any retention cap.
- Identify Release Triggers: Note key dates or milestones such as practical completion, the end of the defects liability period, or other specific events defined in the contract.
- Document Release Dates: Clearly state when retention becomes due for release, referencing the relevant contract clauses and any conditions that must be met.
Clear Presentation Format
4. Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
Typical Errors
- Omitting retention details entirely: Always include the section, even if to state "Nil retention applicable".
- Incorrect percentage application: Double-check contract terms, as different rates might apply to different work portions.
- Failing to track partial releases: Maintain a detailed ledger of all retention releases and reference payment certificates.
- Miscalculating release dates: Use actual certified dates, not estimates, and account for any defects affecting the release.
Best Practices
- Create a dedicated retention tracking spreadsheet.
- Cross-reference your calculations with the respondent's payment schedules.
- Update calculations with each new payment claim.
- Document any disputes regarding retention separately.
5. Risks of Not Including This Information
| Risk Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Legal Risks | Claims may be rejected for being incorrectly calculated. Lack of clarity can lead to an unfavourable adjudication determination. |
| Financial Risks | Failing to claim due retention releases directly impacts cash flow. You may also lose the right to claim interest on overdue amounts. |
| Dispute Risks | Ambiguity increases the likelihood of payment schedule disputes, prolonging resolution times and eroding trust. |
| Strategic Disadvantages | An unclear claim weakens your position in adjudication and reduces leverage in any settlement negotiations. |
6. Examples
Standard Building Contract
Subcontract with Staged Release
7. Related Fields
Accurate retention calculations impact several other key areas of your payment claim:
- Amount Claimed: The final amount claimed must correctly reflect all retention deductions and releases.
- Calculation of Amount: Your workings should show retention as a clear, separate line item.
- Supporting Documentation: You may need to attach certificates that confirm milestones for retention release.
- Previous Payments: The history of payments should reconcile with the cumulative retention held.
8. Frequently Asked Questions
Automate Retention Tracking and Secure Your Cash Flow
Our platform eliminates manual errors, ensures timely claims for retention release, and keeps your projects financially healthy.
Schedule DemoContract Administration for NSW Construction
Our team provides strategic contract administration and project management services that streamline your workflows, improve cash flow, and reduce compliance risks.
Serving: Residential builders, commercial subcontractors, and developers across NSW construction projects
Schedule Demo